Tournament: Gonzaga | Round: 2 | Opponent: Saint Francis GR | Judge: Brian Gaston
The Affirmative identifies Mexico as an uncivilized, non-law abiding land with a lack of rule of law. Their prescription is to export the American system of law, through international organizations like the ILO, to “civilize” Mexican law. This is a neoliberal intervention which recreates a colonial form of legal dominiance.
Mattei 09 (Ugo Mattei, Professor at Hastings College of the Law – “Global Law and Plunder: The Dark Side of the Rule of Law” - http://works.bepress.com/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1014andcontext=bocconi_legal_papers – 2009)
Within this framework, Western law has ... weak concept of ‘rule of law’.
The exportation of Western law to countries like Mexico represents a form of neo-colonial empire. The use of international organizations like the ILO is a tool to subtly extort Mexico into complying with Western legal systems.
Mattei 09 (Ugo Mattei, Professor at Hastings College of the Law – “Global Law and Plunder: The Dark Side of the Rule of Law” - http://works.bepress.com/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1014andcontext=bocconi_legal_papers – 2009)
There is a clear pattern of continuity ... developing’ and former socialist world.
Rather than being a rational, objective tool, the liberal law imposed by the Affirmative masks racism and colonialism.
Dossa 99 (Shiraz Dossa, Professor in the Department of Political Science at St. Francis Xhavier University – “Liberal Legalism: Law, Culture and Identity” – The European Legacy, Vol. 4, No. 3, pp. 73-87)
No discipline in the rationalized ... the perpetual foreigner.
Eurocentrism shapes traditional policymaking knowledge production – the state, and democratic processes are universalized and spread with policies like the plan
Frankzi, University of London, Birkbeck College, School of Law, Graduate Student, 12
(Hannah, Center for InterAmerican Studies, Bielefeld University, Universitat Bielefeld, “Eurocentrism,” http://elearning.uni-bielefeld.de/wikifarm/fields/ges_cias/field.php/Main/Unterkapitel52, Accessed: 7/3/13, LPS.)
Researchers contributing ... can inspire new methodologies.
COLONIALISM IS LIFE IN HELL – IT IS THE TESTING GROUND FOR THE GREATEST HORRORS
MALDONADO-TORRES 08 (Nelson, Asst. Prof. Ethnic Studies, U.C. Berkeley, Against War pp. 217-18.)
Dussel, Quijano, and Wynter ... so-called postmodern world.
THE COLONIAL WORLD GUARANTEES A PERMANENT INESCAPABLE STATE OF WAR
MALDONADO-TORRES 08 (Nelson, Asst. Prof. Ethnic Studies, U.C. Berkeley, Against War pp. 218.)
Race emerges within a permanent state of exception ... colonized subjects cannot evade or escape.
Their impact arguments are all constructs of representations — a Western standpoint is
incapable of describing reality — this means that first, representations outweigh
because they create reality in this instance, and second, their impact narratives are not
accurate
Bogues 06 (Anthony, Ph.D. in political theory from University of West Indies, Brown African Studies Dept., "After Man: Towards the Human," p. 19-21)
The question of objectivity ... and stable replication as a form of life.40
ALTERNATIVE: EPISTEMIC DECOLONIAL SHIFT
MIGNOLO 06 (Walter, Prof. Literature and Romance Studies, Duke U., American Literary History 2006 pp.313-14.)
The changes I am thinking ... the population of Central Asia.
ALTERNATVE SOLVES -- BORDER THINKING OPENS A NEW WAY OF THINKING THAT OPENS THE DOOR TO SUPERCEEDING COLINIALITY
MIGNOLO 00 (Walter, Prof. Literature and Romance Studies, Duke U, Local Histories/Global Designs pp. 317.)
Inside and outside ... and the colonial difference
ONLY THE DAMNES PERSPETIVE CAN SOLVE – THE IMPERIAL PERSPECITVE OF THE PLAN BLOCKS SOLVENCY
MIGNOLO 05 (Walter, Prof. Literature and Romance Studies, Duke U, The Idea of Latin America pp. 155-57.)
The colonial wound, ... marketing success.
ONLY DECOLONIAL EPISTEMIC SHIFT BY ITSELF SOLVES – ANY ACTION WITHIN THE CURRENT EPISTEME PREVENTS OTHER EPISTEMIC PERSPECTIVES
MIGNOLO 06 (Walter, Prof. Literature and Romance Studies, Duke U., American Literary History 2006 p.324.)
It is my contention that... postmodern and the postcolonial.